Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically
Abelardo Rodriguez Gonzalez
Psychologist, Technician of Special Programme Service
Program of Social Services Alternative to Psychiatric Institutionalisation
General Directorate of Social Services, Health and Social Services Committee
Madrid Autonomous Regional Council
Felipe Jouron Gonzalez
Psychologist, Co-ordinator of the Project for the Rehabilitation and
Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill.
Maria Victoria Fernandez Aguirre
Psychologist, Expert in Psychosocial Rehabilitation
Citation: Gonzalez, R.G., Gonzalez, F.J., & Fernandez-Aquirre, M.V. (2001) Rehabilitation and Social Insertion
of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill. International Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation. 5, 79-100
Rehabilitation and social insertion of the homeless chronically mentally ill. Homelessness is undoubtedly the most serious and dramatic expression of all social exclusion phenomena. It affects a growing number of people suffering severe poverty, marginality and abandonment. Serious mental illness shows up within the group of homeless that survive on the streets or live in shelters. The severe mentally ill, which constitute an especially marginal group, have raised much social concern. In Spain there are precious few initiatives aimed at the care and rehabilitation of the homeless mentally ill. One particularly notable intervention took place in Madrid in 1991, the "Project for the Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill", funded by the Health and Social Services Committee of the Madrid Regional Council, with support from the Social Services Department of the Madrid City Council. This article reviews problems of homelessness with special reference to the above-mentioned project, whose structure, organisation, main actions, intervention strategies, results and impact will be described. Finally, future perspectives and recommendations concerning the care of the homeless are discussed.
The fundamental objective of the present article is to consider the situation of a group –the homeless chronic mentally ill– about which little is known and to which scant attention is paid, and which involves a combination of two dimensions, those of mental health and social exclusion. In addition, and especially, it aims to describe a project designed specifically to aid the rehabilitation and social reintegration of people in this situation: the "Project for the Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill", developed initially as a "New Initiative" within the framework of the European Commission’s POVERTY 3 Programme (1990-1994), and that continued to function after the termination of Poverty 3 in 1994. This Project is the responsibility of the Health and Social Services Committee of the Madrid Regional Council, and is supported by the Social Services Department of the Madrid City Council. During its stage as a "New Initiative" of Poverty 3 it also enjoyed the support and co-funding of the then General Directorate of Social Action of the Ministry of Social Affairs, and of the European Commission.
Its essential purpose was (and continues to be) that of developing innovative strategies that aid the rehabilitation and progressive social reintegration of the homeless chronically mentally ill, a much-neglected population that has emerged over recent years as part of the complex phenomenon of "homelessness".
We shall describe the structure and organisation of the Project, together with its principal actions and intervention strategies, its results and its impact. Finally, we shall draw some conclusions about its effectiveness and future perspectives, and offer some general recommendations for improving the situation of this community and the attention it receives.
MENTAL HEALTH AND SOCIAL EXCLUSION: The homeless chronically mentally ill
Homelessness is, without doubt, the most serious and dramatic expression of the phenomenon of social exclusion (Cáritas, 1996). It affects an ever-increasing number of persons and groups that suffer serious conditions of poverty, marginalisation and abandonment.
The term "homeless persons" refers to a group and a social problem with varied and heterogeneous characteristics, profiles and necessities, but with a series of common dimensions: severe poverty, social isolation, rootlessness, breakdown of social and family bonds, personal deterioration and lack of a place (a home) to cover needs of accommodation and social support. The phenomenon is a highly urban one, characteristic of large cities in which problems of poverty, rootlessness and isolation are exacerbated, and lead to exclusion processes (which form the basis of the problem) being expressed in the most extreme and inhuman way in situations of homelessness (Rodriguez Díaz, 1987).
Homeless persons do not constitute a homogeneous group; on the contrary, this is a group with diffuse boundaries and heterogeneous composition and characteristics. In contrast to the typical profile of the "tramp" or "vagrant" of 20 years ago (male, aged around 40, with no profession or trade, working sporadically or marginally, itinerant for reasons of seasonal employment and due to a reliance on hostels and shelters, with problems of alcoholism, etc.), today’s profile is new, differentiated and multiple (women, one-parent families, young people, long-term unemployed) and with new problems (drug-dependence, mental illness, disorders such as tuberculosis or AIDS, etc.). The phenomenon of homelessness is clearly of considerable magnitude, as evidenced by the different annual reports drawn up by the European Observatory for the Homeless and co-ordinated by FEANTSA (European Federation of Services for Homeless Persons) (Daly, 1993; Drake, 1994; Avramov, 1996). Nevertheless, it is difficult to quantify this problem due to the absence –at either national or European level– of a universal definition of "Homeless Persons" (HPs) and the extreme scarcity of epidemiological statistics or studies on the phenomenon.
Within the community of HPs living in the streets or in hostels and shelters, cases of severe mental illness have been detected. The homeless seriously mentally ill constitute an especially marginalised group, and have given rise to considerable social concern. This situation is particularly serious in the large cities of the United States. Diverse studies carried out in that country estimate that between 25% and 50% of adult homeless suffer from severe or chronic mental illness (Lamb, 1984; Arce and Vergare, 1984; Bassuk, 1984 and 1986; U.S. GAO, 1988). However, many of the early studies presented various methodological difficulties related to sampling biases, failure to use standardised procedures, lack of a consistent definition of "mental illness", etc., which led to overestimations of the prevalence of these disorders among the homeless population. In recent years, several studies have been carried out using improved sampling systems and more appropriate diagnoses based on structured interviews such as the DIS or the CIDI (Composite International Diagnostic Interview). These studies indicate that between 25% and 35% of HPs present some kind of serious mental disorder (such as schizophrenia, severe depression, dysthimia or cognitive deterioration), and that 30% to 50% abuse alcohol or drugs. A summary of the most relevant data found in these studies is presented in Box 1.
Box 1. Data on lifetime prevalence of DSM-III mental disorders
from various epidemiological studies carried out on homeless in the U.S.A.
compared with the ECA study on the general population
Until quite recently, there was scarcely any reliable data on the Spanish homeless population in general, and still less on the problem of their mental health. Some of the data was based on estimations, or on the records of centres for the homeless. For example, Solé (1994) estimated that among
Barcelona’s homeless population approximately 1 in 3 suffered from some kind of mental disorder according to the DSM III-R or CIE-10, in the following proportions: 5% organic mental disorders, 10% schizophrenia or delirium, and 20% depression. Fortunately, some specific and rigorous epidemiological studies have recently been carried out in this area. Two of these deserve special attention: that carried out in Madrid by Manuel Muñoz, Carmelo Vázquez and Juan Antonio Cruzado (1995), and that carried out in Gijón by Luis Santiago Vega (1996).
An analysis of the data from these studies clearly reveals that there is a higher incidence of schizophrenia among the homeless population than in the normal population (see data from the ECA study in Box 1); it is also clear, however, that in no way does the problem involve a majority, as some would argue, stating that "the streets are full of mentally ill people". Depressive disorders are more frequent (as they are among the general population), which seems reasonable if we take into account the lamentable conditions in which HPs live.
In the mentioned studies from Spain, more than 50% of the interviewees presented none of the serious mental disorders assessed. The available data would therefore appear not to corroborate the hypothesis of homelessness being caused by mental illness. This should by no means, however, lead us to minimise the importance of the problem of mental health among the homeless; rather, on the basis of this type of study, appropriate measures of prevention, attention and rehabilitation should be promoted.
As we have indicated, the problem of homelessness is complex, and multidimensional in its causes, processes and results. It is therefore difficult to establish with any kind of rigour causal and temporal relationships between mental illness and homelessness. From the existing data it would not appear very likely that mental disorders constitute the main cause of homelessness, nor that severe psychiatric problems have a majority presence among homeless persons; nor can it be maintained, especially in the case of Spain, that the processes of psychiatric reform and disinstitutionalisation (Desviat, 1996) have had a decisive influence on the increased numbers of mentally ill in situations of homelessness.
Evidently, the conditions in which homeless people live and the isolation and social rejection they suffer are factors that can precipitate or facilitate the appearance of psychiatric disorders. Moreover, it should not be forgotten that the presence of serious mental illnesses may constitute an element that aggravates social exclusion situations, and helps to maintain them if the appropriate treatment and support is not provided.
Specific attention to the homeless chronically mentally ill in our country is scarce and inadequate. Networks of attention resources for the homeless (Institute of Spanish Public Opinion Studies, 1990), already limited, often find themselves overloaded and overwhelmed due to the psychiatric and psychosocial problems of the severely and chronically mentally ill.
Given their situation and condition of severe social exclusion, many of the homeless mentally ill do not regularly use or take full advantage of mental health services –and the situation is much more serious among those living rough in the streets, who do not use hostels or support centres at all.
It is fundamental for mental health services to prioritise the development of more responsive and flexible programmes that can be adapted to the peculiarities and characteristics of this group, and can offer them the treatment and attention they need. Furthermore, the serious inadequacy of community social resources for rehabilitation, residential attention and support for the chronically mentally ill population is exacerbating and maintaining the situation of exclusion and marginalisation of many homeless mentally ill.
In sum, it is clear that attention to this community is negative and deficient. There are few specific initiatives being developed in Spain in relation to the homeless mentally ill. It is for this reason that special mention should be made of a project under way in Madrid since 1990: the "Project for the Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill", run by the Health and Social Services Committee of the Madrid Regional Council (through the Programme of Social Services Alternative to Psychiatric Institutionalisation) and developed with the collaboration of Madrid City Council’s Social Services Department and San Isidro Shelter.
This project began in 1990, and from then until 1994 it formed part –as a "New Initiative"– of the European Commission’s POVERTY 3 Programme. It continuous to function. The objective of the Project is to attend to people with serious psychiatric disorders that are using or in contact with the San Isidro Municipal Shelter, and to offer them there, through a team of specialists, individualised programmes of psychosocial rehabilitation and community support in order to increase their personal and social autonomy and improve their chances of social reintegration. The work is carried out in close collaboration with the local mental health services. The Project also has 4 supervised flats, capable of accommodating up to 18 people, which serve as back-up resources for the rehabilitation and social reintegration of those attended.
This project does not pretend to be a panacea, nor the solution for all Madrid’s homeless mentally ill; rather, it is a specific experience that has demonstrated that the homeless chronically mentally ill in situations of serious psychosocial deterioration and social exclusion can live a normal and dignified life in the community if they are offered appropriate and flexible attention and support. We have seen the success of a methodology of rehabilitation and support, based on a responsive and individualised style of attention, that has made possible the active involvement of service users, and contributed to a substantial improvement in their quality of life and increased their independence and possibilities of social reintegration. This experience might serve as a basis for improving programmes of attention, rehabilitation and reinsertion aimed at the homeless chronically mentally ill. In the following sections we shall describe the main characteristics, activities and results of the Project (for a more detailed review, see the Reports of 1988/93 and 1994/96 of the Programme of Social Services Alternative to Psychiatric Institutionalisation (PSSAPI), of which the Project forms a part).
A PSYCHOSOCIAL INTERVENTION IN THE MADRID AUTONOMOUS REGION: The Project for the Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill (PRISEMI)
Antecedents and context of the project
The Project for the Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill (hereinafter referred to as "the Project" or "PRISEMI") was developed in 1989 in a context in which two factors were prominent:
b) The development in the Madrid Autonomous Region of a model of community attention, committed to the attention to and maintenance of the chronically mentally ill in their social environment via a set of treatment, rehabilitation and support services.
In developing and extending community attention to the chronically mentally ill, the presence was detected of homeless people with mental disorders. During the 1980s, there was a notable increase in the homeless population of Madrid. 1988 data indicated the network of services for the homeless had attended to a total of 10,628 persons, over half of them for the first time. At the same time as this increase in numbers, a qualitative change had occurred in the composition and problems of this population. Thus, according to figures from the Madrid City Council, which estimated that 28% of people using the services of the San Isidro Municipal Shelter in 1988 suffered from serious mental health problems, an increase was recorded in the number of persons among this group with psychiatric disorders.
This apparent increase of the number of mentally ill in marginal situations constitutes a new and complex social phenomenon, as yet barely known and little researched. It has arisen in recent years in a context of crisis and economic and social transformation, in which new forms of poverty and social exclusion have been generated and the number of homeless people has increased.
The appearance and apparent increase in the number of "mentally ill in the streets", persons living in poverty and without a home, must be understood within this context of "the new poor"; these people constitute one of the groups in which homelessness and social exclusion are combined in a serious way. Marginal lifestyles, isolation, lack of family and social support, lack of economic resources, psychiatric disorders, personal and social deterioration –these are some of the elements that converge in this group, forming a vicious circle of poor conditions, marginality and exclusion. This situation is worsened by the fact that many of these people do not use the social and health services available, and tend to be reluctant to become properly involved in attention programmes.
The appearance, then, of the new phenomenon of the so-called "mentally ill in the streets", with their special characteristics, represents an important challenge for social and health services in general, who must try to adjust to their peculiarities and respond to their needs, making possible an improvement in their quality of life and their gradual social insertion.
Given this situation, it became necessary to design specific measures oriented to this group in order to understand their problem and its extent and to develop actions designed to improve attention to them and facilitate their progressive social reintegration. Furthermore, it was (and is) fundamental to promote the development of a comprehensive network of resources for attention to, and the rehabilitation/social reinsertion of those with serious and chronic mental illnesses to prevent their becoming marginalised and facilitate the normalisation of attention to the specific treatment, rehabilitation and residential support needs of the homeless chronically mentally ill.
In this line, the Programme of Social Services Alternative to Psychiatric Institutionalisation, developed by (as it was then called) the Social Reintegration Committee of the Madrid Autonomous Region, targeted the specific social needs of the chronically mentally ill, taking advantage of the European Commission’s "Poverty 3" programme of 1990. In collaboration with the Social Services Department of the Madrid City Council, a project was designed with the aim of organising and putting into practice specific actions designed to approach this group, understand its problems and, through better attention, improve its situation.
Thus emerged the "Project for the Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill" as a "New Initiative" within the Poverty 3 programme (1990-1994). The organisational structure of the Project was framed within a model of co-operation and collaboration among various public bodies (Madrid Autonomous Region, Madrid City Council, Ministry of Social Affairs and the European Commission):
- The Madrid City Council, through its Social Services Department, and specifically the Section of Attention to the Homeless and the San Isidro Municipal Shelter, is the body whose collaboration and participation was essential for the planning, development and follow-up of the Project. Its collaboration was (and continues to be) particularly helpful with regard to the provision of work spaces at the San Isidro Municipal Shelter and the participation of its professionals in the development of the psychosocial rehabilitation and community support activities organised by the Project in its work with the chronically mentally ill using the Shelter.
- The Ministry of Social Affairs, through the General Directorate of Social Action, provided funding and technical support for the Project.
- The European Commission, through the administration and coordination structures of the Poverty 3 programme, gave support and technical advice, as well as the funding it provided until the end of the programme in 1994.
The following sections are devoted to a description of its main characteristics, actions and results.
General description and principal features
The Project for the Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill emerged, then, as an attempt to develop innovative measures of social intervention with the chronically mentally ill, who had begun to become visible among the homeless population. Little was known about this new type of homeless person, and data from studies on the extent and characteristics of the problem was scarce.
Its aim was to carry out positive interventions with respect to this socially excluded group, offering them attention programmes, psychosocial rehabilitation and community support, together with housing alternatives that would help to increase their independence and quality of life and make possible their progressive social reintegration.
As already stated, the Project’s target population is that living in Madrid (permanently or temporarily), homeless, and suffering from chronic mental illness, and therefore suffering from the effects of two adverse situations and their interaction.
Those included in the category of the chronically mentally ill are characterised by the following features (Talbott, 1984; Liberman 1988/1993):
- Psychosocial deterioration with regard to three or more aspects of everyday life, including personal hygiene, self-care, interpersonal relationships, social skills, etc., which hinders the development or maintenance of their economic self-sufficiency and their independent coping in the community.
- A history of psychiatric attention, with hospitalisation that may be long-term (one year or more in the last five years), medium-term (ninety days to a year in the last year) or short-term (less than ninety days). This feature is not common to all chronically mentally ill, some of whom may simply have attended local medical centres, or even received no type of attention at all.
- Medical attention: this is crucial, since, due to the poor diet, hygiene and self-care conditions of this group, its mortality and morbidity rates are higher than those of the rest of the population.
- Psychiatric attention: diagnosis, psychopharmacological treatment, crisis intervention and hospitalisation where necessary.
- Psychosocial rehabilitation: training in self-care, social skills and adaptation to the community; support for integration and maintenance in the community.
- Employment rehabilitation: prevocational, vocational and occupational training, and support for finding employment and adaptation to work.
- Residential support in the community: graded residential services according to the different levels of independence and following the principle of the least restrictive alternative.
- Economic support.
The problem is to create a situation whereby this group is able to accede to and benefit from these services in an appropriate way. It is therefore necessary to develop active, search-based formulas that allow us to reach this population wherever they are, to understand their problems and to put them in touch with the network of services; at the same time, there is a need to work towards improving their capacities and increasing their independence, so that they are able to take advantage of the services they need, and can gradually progress in the direction of social reintegration.
FEATURES OF THE PROJECT
With the above in mind, the Project was designed with the following characteristics or defining elements:
2) To make more dynamic and strengthen coordination between the existing social/health services in order to favour integral attention to this population. This project neither should nor could pretend to cover all the multiple and varied needs of the homeless chronically mentally ill, but rather it is necessary to develop coordination among the different services already in place, especially those of mental health and general social services, with the aim of promoting their involvement in attention to the psychiatric and social needs of these people and in supporting their access to and use of these services.
3) To make accessible to the reference population programmes of psychosocial rehabilitation, aimed at increasing their independence and preparing them for integration in the community. Such programmes, which do not normally reach this group, were to be run at the San Isidro Municipal Shelter. Moreover, and with a view to creating opportunities to break away from the circuit of homelessness and marginalisation, 4 supervised flats, catering for up to 18 people, were made available.
4) To frame the project in an environment of inter-institutional collaboration (Madrid Regional Council, Madrid City Council and Ministry of Social Affairs), thus permitting access to considerable technical and financial resources, and the promotion of the Project as a measure for improving the quality of life and possibilities of social insertion of this group.
5) To design a dynamic and flexible project, capable of being readjusted as better knowledge of the realities and needs of this group and the experience and results themselves allow an assessment of the effectiveness and relevance of the actions carried out, so that the possibilities of its rehabilitation and social reintegration can be maximised. This means that the Project was conceived as a kind of "bank of tests", allowing not only better knowledge of the problems and situation of this group, but also the type of resources, actions and programmes necessary for adapting and complementing the existing services, including the Project itself.
To this end, the Project proposed the development of a rigorous epidemiological study for the analysis and detection of the quantity, psychiatric and psychosocial problems and characteristics of those with serious and chronic mental disorders in situations of homelessness. Likewise, it sought to advance the study of the factors that led to their becoming homeless.
- On the other hand, an Intervention-Specific Action dimension aimed at the group of chronically mentally ill (around 60) using or in contact with Madrid City Council’s San Isidro Municipal Shelter, the principal public resource providing attention to homeless persons.
Given the philosophy of rehabilitation underlying the Project, the participation of users in their rehabilitation process and in the control of their own lives is an objective and an instrument essential to the intervention. Thus, in a gradual but continuous way, those making up the target population of the Project were encouraged to become involved in the planning of their own process of reinsertion, and in the definition of their objectives. After all, the ultimate aim of rehabilitation is to help these people to overcome their problems and recover their capacity to make decisions and move away from exclusion and deterioration towards normalisation and integration.
For this purpose, the Project had the support of the following team:
- 1 Psychologist
- 6 Instructors
In summary, the main actions and intervention strategies of the Project are:
Programmes of psychosocial rehabilitation and community support
The Project aimed, as a basic pillar of the intervention, to reach the group of homeless chronically mentally ill using the San Isidro Municipal Shelter and to offer them individualised programmes of psychosocial rehabilitation and community support (Rodríguez, 1997), with the purpose of:
- Supporting and strengthening their links with the existing social and health services, especially with mental health services, attending to their needs for psychiatric treatment, but also with general social services and other specific services for the chronically mentally ill, as well as other socio-community resources, in order to increase their possibilities of social integration.
- Preparing, facilitating and supporting their progressive social reinsertion.
However, in spite of these positive effects, the Project’s potential for facilitating the social reinsertion of many of the target population is limited by the insufficiency of residential alternatives and social support in the community.
Residential alternatives in the community
In order to facilitate leaving the San Isidro Municipal Shelter and to favour the social reintegration of the mentally ill using its services and reached by the Project, four supervised flats (18 places) were made available, to serve as housing alternatives and support, and as a context for favouring the process of rehabilitation and social reintegration.
These flats received support that was flexible and adapted to the needs of users by the Project team.
The flats have been seen to work well and constitute a positive element of the Project, as a flexible residential alternative, providing an opportunity to live in a normal community and enjoy its support, and thus as a context for moving towards social reintegration. Those benefiting form them have experienced a radical improvement in quality of life: having a home of their own has made it possible for them to recover their dignity and self-esteem, and to change their role of marginalised persons or patients for those of active, normal people. Functioning at an internal level has been interesting, with the achievement of high levels of independence and self-organisation in everyday life, as well as normalisation of the users’ current situation and perspectives for integration.
The Project was responsible for organising various training and technical support programmes with the following personnel:
- The auxiliary staff of the San Isidro Municipal Shelter, with the aim of increasing their knowledge of the chronically mentally ill population and providing them with strategies for improving rehabilitatory attention to chronically mentally ill persons using the Shelter.
As already explained, the aim of the Project was to develop an epidemiological study that would provide rigorous, valid and reliable data on the number, social and demographic characteristics, and types of psychiatric problem of the homeless mentally ill, and to make progress in the analysis of the factors that have influenced their becoming marginalised.
This research was carried out by the Psychology Faculty of Madrid’s Complutense University under the direction of Manuel Muñoz, Carmelo Vázquez and Juan Antonio Cruzado, and in accordance with an agreement with the Committee. It concluded in 1994 and was published the following year, by the Regional Council of Madrid, as a book entitled: "Homeless Persons in Madrid: A Psychosocial and Epidemiological Report."
Its main results have already been presented, and have also been summarised by Muñoz and Vázquez in other studies.
Sumary of attention provided by the proyect 1990-1996
We shall continue by offering a summary of the development of the Project and the attention provided during the period 1990-1996 (see PSSAPI reports of 88/93 and 94/96).
The following table presents the main data referring to attention provided by the project from its inception in 1990 until 31st December, 1996.
During this period
a total of 109 persons were attended. As can be observed in Table 1 and
Graph 1, the project’s attention capacity increased continuously, reaching
a maximum of 83 users, with figures of around 70 simultaneous users. The
rate of new users, after reaching figures of up to 22 per year in the early
years, stabilised in the last three years at a mean of 14 users/year.
Table 1. Evolution of Attention in the PRISEMI Project
Graph 1. Basic descriptive statistics of effect size
From the opening of the Project’s first two supervised flats, in 1992, up to the present, with 4 flats available, the team has made a considerable effort, in collaboration with the professionals at the San Isidro Municipal Shelter (SIMS), to offer users living in the SIMS more normal alternatives –not only their own flats, but also boarding houses or flats shared among several SIMS users. Supervision in these other residential alternatives has also been carried out by the Project team, and always in accordance with the circumstances of each case.
Openings for returning to the family environment continue to be limited, given the lengthy periods of separation usually involved in these cases and the mutual difficulty of adaptation, but those that have occurred have been aided by a previous stage of living in the supervised flats.
The result of the team’s work, as observed in Table 2, is that by 31st December 1996, only 48.5% of users attended by the Project were living in the SIMS. The remainder, i.e., 51.4%, were living in more normal alternative accommodation: boarding houses, shared flats and Project flats. All of those attaining these alternatives had come from the San Isidro Municipal Shelter.
Table 2. Place of residence of Project users
The total number of places in supervised flats currently managed by the Project is 18. On 31st December 1996, 17 were occupied. The remaining place became vacant on its occupant moving to another normal housing alternative, and the place was kept free while the person’s adaptation to the new environment was assessed.
In general, as can
be seen from Table 3, the level of continuity in the flats is high. Since
1992, 5 persons have left (without moving to alternative accommodation),
but of these five, the team continues to help or to maintain contact with
four. Only one of them has decided to separate from the Project completely.
Table 3. Evolution of stay in supervised project flats
The number of those leaving the flats for a positive alternative is also low (3). Although users’ contacts with their families increase significantly on moving to a more normalised environment, such as a supervised flat, this proximity rarely leads to a return to the family home. Other alternatives for positive moves, such as renting flats, are beyond the economic possibilities of the users, whose opportunities for integration in the world of work (with mean ages of 40 years and little training or work experience) are scarce.
In total, throughout the history of the Project, 18 people have made positive moves (3 of them, as indicated, from the supervised flats). The residential destination of these 18 users is shown in Table 4:
Table 4. Evolution of Positive Moves from the Project
The total number of those moving to more positive alternatives represents 16.5% of those attended, and has mainly occurred since 1993, one year after the team began to intensify its work of enabling people to leave the Municipal Shelter and move to alternative accommodation. As it can be seen, the majority of these cases (two-thirds) involved moves to shared flats or homes (Senior Citizen’s Residences or Instituto José Germain).
Table 5 shows the data on the use of other resources of the PSSAPI Programme in which the Project is included and of other community resources by users of the Project (those living in the SIMS and in other residential alternatives) between 1993 and 1996.
Table 5. Use of other socio-community resources
Graphic 2. Use of community resources 1993-1996
Despite the fact that the use of other resources of the PSSAPI is not particularly high, since the weight of rehabilitation falls mainly on the Project, considerable efforts have been made to encourage users to take advantage of community resources of all kinds. Figures for the last two years show that 70% of Project users benefit to some extent from employment and leisure services. These figures represent an increase with respect to those of previous years.
The sociodemographic data that characterises those attended by the Project are, in summary, as follows (for further details see the PSSAPI Report 1994/1996): with regard to sex, approximately 60% of those attended are women and 40% are men; mean age is 43 years; the vast majority (63%) are unmarried; schizophrenia is the most common disorder; there is a low educational level, with 53% having only elementary education and 20% education to age 15; they are unemployed and not receiving benefit (42%), or receiving a pension (55%), in the majority of cases a non-contributory disability pension; the vast majority (79%) have no criminal record; since being attended by the Project 83% have not been admitted to hospital due to psychiatric crisis.
Summary and perspectives
Let us consider the main conclusions reached by the Project, which form the basis of experience on which its work can be continued:
- We have moved much closer to the problems, needs and characteristics of the homeless chronically mentally ill, and gained a much better and more comprehensive knowledge of their situation.
- A methodology of psychosocial rehabilitation and flexible community support, adapted to the needs of this population, has been successfully used. This has made possible their active involvement and contributed to an improvement in their situation and quality of life and an increase in their autonomy and possibilities of social reintegration.
- The suitability of the accommodation alternatives (supervised flats) developed by the Project has been demonstrated: these normalised and normalising alternatives have made possible a substantial improvement in the quality of life of the target group and increased their chances of social reintegration.
- Involvement and coordination with mental health services and other socio-community services in attending to this group have been strengthened and improved.
- A model of inter-institutional
co-operation has been developed through the Project. This is an essential
condition for comprehensive attention to the population in question and
in general in the fight against the exclusion and in favour of the integration
of the homeless.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
We should like to conclude
this work by considering a series of recommendations (among many others)
that we feel to be pertinent, with a view to improving the situation of
the homeless mentally ill and offering them the integral attention they
- Given the characteristics of this population it is necessary to continue developing specific actions aimed at them that will serve as a basis for attention to them and their rehabilitation. These actions should complement the efforts of the general systems of social protection and those of specific social and health networks for giving attention to, rehabilitating and providing community support for the mentally ill.
- It is highly important to plan and develop integral programmes and projects for attending to the entire homeless chronically mentally ill population in the large cities in Spain, including not only those attended by or in contact with the various shelters and hostels, but also those living rough on the streets.
- The programmes and interventions to be developed should be based on the appropriate studies and research that permit the detection of the population to be attended and provide reliable quantitative and qualitative data on their situation, characteristics and problems.
- These interventions, although necessarily specific, should be integrated and/or coordinated in a coherent and synergic way with general planning of attention to the homeless population, and with planning or systems of mental health and social services for community attention to the population with chronic mental illnesses.
- Measures taken should cover the different levels involved: prevention, attention, rehabilitation and social reintegration.
- From the logic of the principle of multidimensionality, all the different needs and problems of this population (detection and reach, basic needs, accommodation, psychiatric treatment and follow-up, psychosocial rehabilitation, community support, economic self-sufficiency, etc.) should be covered in a comprehensive way, with the overall objective of facilitating their integration and maintenance in the community in the best possible conditions of autonomy, quality of life and normalisation.
- Both the organisation and development of the necessary specific resources and programmes and the involvement and adjustment of the various existing networks of community services (mental health, general and specialized rehabilitation and social support, hospitals, etc.) should be taken into account in the planning of integral attention to this population, avoiding the creation of parallel networks or unnecessary duplication that may lead to marginalisation. Likewise, it is essential that the network of attention, rehabilitation and social support for the chronically mentally ill be endowed with sufficient resources to be able to include the homeless.
- As specific and priority measures to be developed with the homeless mentally ill, intensive actions should be designed –from a "search-based" perspective– that aim to detect and reach this group (specialised teams for attention and advice in the street, flexible "bridges" adapted to their characteristics –day centres, "no questions asked" accommodation, etc.–, rehabilitation and follow-up programmes for those living rough) and aid their progressive involvement in more normalised attention programmes and resources. Also, efforts should be made by mental health services to offer, in a flexible and responsive way, the psychiatric help this population requires.
- With regard to the group of chronically mentally ill attended by or in contact with the shelters, the development of flexible and individualised programmes of psychosocial rehabilitation and community support, together with the launching of an adequate range of supervised accommodation resources in the community, should constitute one of the main pillars of the intervention.
- These programmes
and interventions should be structured by promoting the involvement in
planning and management, not only of health and social service administrations
at their various levels (central, regional and municipal), but also of
all the social bodies and organisations that work with the homeless, and
whose coordinated collaboration is fundamental for the optimum and effective
development of the plan and its different strategies.
Avramov, D. (1996): El fenómeno de los sin techo en la Unión Europea (The phenomenon of the homeless in the European Union). Fourth Report of the European Observatory for the Homeless. FEANTSA.
Ayuntamiento de Madrid (1986): Transeúntes e indigentes. Estados de necesidad y respuesta social (The transient and the needy. States of necessity and social response). Madrid, Concejalía de Servicios Sociales.
Ayuntamiento de Madrid (1989): Memoria del Centro de Acogida Municipal San Isidro (Report of the San Isidro Municipal Shelter). Área de Servicios Sociales del Ayuntamiento de Madrid,
Bassuk, E.L., Rubin, L. and Lauriat, A.S. (1984): Is homelessness a mental health problem? American Journal of Psychiatry, 141, 1546-1550.
Bassuk, E.L., Rubin, L. and Lauriat, A.S. (1986): Characteristics of homeless sheltered families. American Journal of Public Health, 76, 1097-1101.
CARITAS (1996): Volver a Ser: Modelo de Intervención Social con Transeuntes (Starting Over: Model of Social Intervention with Transient People). Madrid. Programa de transeuntes y colectivos sin techo, CARITAS España.
EUROPEAN COMMISSION (1989): "Decision of the Commission relating to the implementation of a medium-term programme of measures for the economic and social integration of the economically and socially least-favoured categories of persons". Official Diary of the European Communities. Brussels, 28-VIII-1989.
Consejería de Integración Social (1994): Memoria final de la Iniciativa Innovadora nº 32 del Programa Europeo Pobreza 3: Proyecto de Rehabilitación e Inserción Social de Enfermos Mentales Crónicos sin Hogar (Final report of New Initiative Nº 32 of the European Programme POVERTY 3. Project for the Rehabilitation and Social Insertion of the Homeless Chronically Mentally Ill. Madrid. Consejería de Integración Social. Comunidad de Madrid.
Consejería de Sanidad y Servicios Sociales (1988/1995) : Programa de Servicios Sociales Alternativos a la Institucionalización Psiquiátrica (Programme of Social Services Alternative to Psychiatric Institutionalisation). Madrid. Dirección General de Servicios Sociales. Comunidad de Madrid
Consejería de Integración Social (1994): Memoria 1988/1993 del Programa de Servicios Sociales Alternativos a la Institucionalización Psiquiátrica (Report 1988/1993 of the Programme of Social Services Alternative to Psychiatric Institutionalisation). Madrid. Dirección General de Servicios Sociales Especializados. Comunidad de Madrid.
Consejería de Sanidad y Servicios Sociales (1997): Memoria 1994/1996 del Programa de Servicios Sociales Alternativos a la Institucionalización Psiquiátrica (Report 1994/1996 of the Programme of Social Services Alternative to Psychiatric Institutionalisation). Madrid. Dirección General de Servicios Sociales. Comunidad de Madrid.
Daly, M. (1993): Abandonado: Perfil de la gente sin techo en Europa (Abandoned: Profile of the homeless in Europe). Second Report of the European Observatory for the Homeless. FEANTSA.
Desviat, M. (1996): La Reforma Psiquiátrica (Psychiatric Reform). Madrid: Ediciones DOR S.L.
Drake, M.(1994): Lossin techo en Europa y sus derechos (The homeless in Europe and their rights). Third Report the European Observatory for the Homeless. FEANTSA.
Farr, R.K., Koegel, P. and Burnam, A.(1986): A study of homelessness and mental illness in the Skid Row Area of Los Angeles. Los Angeles: Los Angeles County, Dep. of Mental Health.
Fisher, P.H., Shapiro,S., Breakey, W.R., Anthony, J.C. and Kramer, M: (1986): Mental health and social characteristics of the homeless: A survey of mission users. American Journal of Public Health, 76, 333-390.
Fisher, P.H. and Breakey, W.A. (1986): Homelessness and mental health: An overview. International Journal of Mental Health, 14, 6-41.
Gaviria, M, Laparra, M and Aguilar, M. (1995): "Aproximación teórica al concepto de exclusión" ("Theoretical approach to the concept of exclusion"). In Alvarez Uria, F. y Otros: Desigualdad y Pobreza Hoy. Madrid: Ediciones Talasa.
Herrero, Mª I., Sobrino, T. and Rodríguez, A. (1993): "Una iniciativa innovadora en el abordaje de la problemática de los enfermos mentales crónicos sin hogar" ("A new initiative in approaching the problem of the homeless chronically mentally ill"). Trabajo Social Hoy, nº 1, pp. 7-14.
Holloway, S. (1989): Homeless people. In A. Gitterman (Ed): Handbook of social work practice with vulnerable populations. New York: Columbia University Press.
Instituto de Estudios de la Opinión Pública Española (1990): Instituciones de Servicios Sociales para Transeuntes (Social Service Institutions for the Homeless). Madrid. IOPE-ETMAR.
Koegel, P., Burnam, M.A. and Farr, R. (1988): The prevalence of specific psychiatric disorders among homeless individuals in the inner city of Los Angeles. Archives of General Psychiatry, 45, 1085-1092.
Lamb, H.R. (1984): The Homeless Mentally Ill. Washington D.C: American Psychiatric Association.
Liberman, R.P. (ed.) (1988): Psychiatric Rehabilitation of Chronic Mental Patients. Washington D.C.: American Psychiatric Press. Spanish translation: Rehabilitación Integral del Enfermo Mental Crónico. Barcelona. Martínez Roca, 1993.
Muñoz, M., Vázquez, C. and Cruzado, J.A. (1995): Personas sin Hogar en Madrid: Informe psicosocial y epidemiológico (The Homeless in Madrid: A Psychosocial and Epidemiological Report). Madrid: Comunidad de Madrid, Consejería de Integración Social, Serie Informes Técnicos nº 7.
Renes Ayala, V.(1994): Luchar contra la Pobreza Hoy (Fighting Poverty Today). Madrid: Ediciones HOAC.
Rodríguez Diaz, A. (Dir.) (1987): Transeuntes e Indigentes: Estados de respuesta y necesidad (The transient and the needy. States of necessity and social response). Madrid. Ayuntamiento de Madrid, Concejalía de Servicios Sociales.
Rodríguez, A. (coord.) (1997): Rehabilitación Psicosocial de Personas con Trastornos Mentales Crónicos (Psychosocial Rehabilitation of Persons with Chronic Mental Disorders). Madrid: Editorial Pirámide.
Rubio-Spitec, M., Bravo, M. and Canino, G.(1991): La Entrevista Diagnóstica Internacional Compuesta (The Composite International Diagnostic Interview, CIDI). Acta Psiquiátrica y Psicológica de America Latina, 37, 191-204.
Salinas Ramos, F. (1993): Informe Final 1993 del Observatorio Español de los sin Techo (1993 Final Report of the Spanish Observatory for the Homeless). CARITAS Española.
Salinas Ramos, F. and Paniagua, J.(1995): El derecho a la vivienda como factor de integración social (The right to housing as a factor of social integration). Informe Final España 1995 del Observatorio nacional de los Sin Techo. Madrid. CARITAS Española.
Solé, J. (1994): "Enfermos mentales sin hogar" ("The homeless mentally ill"). Revista de Psiquiatría de la Facultad de Medicina de Barcelona, 21, 126-134.
Talbott, J.A. (Ed.) (1984): The Chronic Mental Patient: Five Years Later. New York: Grune and Stratton.
U.S. General Accounting Office (1988): Homeless mentally ill: Problems and options in estimating number and trends. Washington D.C.: GAO.
Vega, L.S. (1996): Salud Mental en población sin hogar: Estudio epidemiológico en Albergues para transeuntes de Gijón (Asturias) (Mental Health in the homeless population: An epidemiological study in hostels for the homeless in Gijón (Asturias)). Oviedo. Servicio de Publicaciones de la Junta del Principado de Asturias, Colección Cuadernos Asturianos de Salud Nº 9.
Copyright © 2000, Southern Development Group,
S.A. All Rights Reserved.
A Private Non-Profit Agency for the good of all, published in the UK & Honduras